EditorMustafa kamal born Lakhimpur district of Assam. He claims that he studied at Al Azhar University of Egypt from 2011 to 2018. Here are some of his controversial statements :
1. “Baitullah (kaba) is a statue of Allah”.
Reality- His claim is totally baseless. It goes against fundamental concept of Islam. Because according to Islam their is no statue of Allah.
2. “Hazrat Muhammed (peace be upon him) is a avatar (Sanskrit:अवतार) of Allah”.
Reality: It goes against the fundamental concept of Islam. According to Islam , Allah don’t take avatar. He sends his messenger to guide people.
3. “Worship of dev-devi (Such as Durga puja) is allowed in Islam”. According to surah no 34 , ayat no 13 , he said that worship of various dev-devi is allowed by Quran.
Reality : Worship of anyone other than Allah is not permitted by Quran. He is trying to establish his claim by saying that Arabic word “timsal” means statue. Actually “timsal” has various meanings such as – Image, statue etc. According to Mufti taqi osmani (an international islamic scholar) image is the correct meaning . and second point is this story was about prophet Suleiman not about Prophet Muhammed (PBUH) . It was not performed or supported by prophet Muhammed (PBUH) . So, it is his wrong interpretation of Quran.
4. My three kalima (كلمة) is-
a) La ilaha illallahu shree ram rasulullah
b) La ilaha illallahu shree krishna rasulullah
c) La ilaha illallahu muhammadur rasulullah.
Reality : It is not the teaching of any authentic book of Islam. His statement can creat unrest in society. If a person try to mixup one religion with another, it may disrespectful for both religion. So, we should not try to mixup different religions . Let it be it’s original form.
5) Leaving beard is a work of shaitan (Assamese: দাড়ি চয়তানে ৰাখে)
Reality: Leaving beard is an oldest retual of human community . This ritual is followed by every messanger including Hazrat Muhammed (PBUH) . Leaving beard is not only a ritual in islam but it is also found various other religious groups . So, a responsible person can’t deliver this type of statements.
History record:
1) After returning from Egypt he was trying to control a madrassa previously run by his father. According to local people of saboti he collected a huge amount of money but not able to give the proper account . In a local meeting, There was a fight among people over madrassa fund account. There after people leave the meeting.
2) First he was trying to defend Islam by debating with islamophobs. There after trying to show himself as a social reformer. Now he is trying to prove various non-islamic retuals from Quran.
3) Various cases has been registered against Mustafa kamal.
a) Case by ulama council of Assam at lakhimapur
b) Case by at NEMSU at Shyampur police station
4) In month of October 2024 Lakhimpur police arrested him but after some days he came out. Again he started his controversial statements in social media .
5) Various Portal, News channel inviting him to give his speech. Why this channels are doing this? Will it helpful for any community ? It is unknown.
6) In a phone call with moulana Nur Alom Saikia, he said that Durga puja is mentioned in sura asar. Their after it goes viral on social media. Then, Moulana Nur Alom Saikia gives answer in various plateforms.
References :
1) Local people about madrassa fund controversy https://www.facebook.com/share/v/188iNvHM1x/
2) Moulana Nur Alam Saikia interview https://www.facebook.com/share/v/1ATwdzYUPT/
3) Case by ulama council of Assam at lakhimapur https://www.facebook.com/share/r/15d9YjQLz8/
4) Case by at NEMSU at Shyampur police station https://www.facebook.com/share/r/18By7wKYAY/
5) Video where is is claiming that baitullah is statue of Allah https://www.facebook.com/share/v/18GauPSDkg/
6) Screenshot of his post about his three kalima
7) Asan Tarjuma Quran by Mufti Taqi Osmani
8) Nur Alam Saikia Facebook page
9) Musfata kamal’s Facebook comment about beard https://www.facebook.com/share/v/1AzoW1XMGu/
